[awsmsc]

I think I already posted this or something similar a couple months back, but I like thinking about this.

Here are the ones I very much want in studio version form:

Pale Scales
Shame (the way they played it live in 1998)
Gossamer
As Rome Burns
Make it Happen (original Backwards Clocks style)

[LostSoul]

Lonely Is The Name
The March Hare
As Rome Burns
Circular Change
When The Cocks Crow

Gossamer is fine as-is, IMO. I only listed stuff that either doesn't exist, or might exist only in demo form. Perhaps some are completed, but we don't know for sure. If we're talking material that we know for a fact exists, then add these in to my list:

-Towers Of Rabble (acoustic demo)
-Speed
-Pug (Blues Death March)
-Peace & Love (acoustic demo)
-99 Floors (acoustic demo)

[RottingApples]

1. Speed (1995)
2. Orpheus Descending (keyboard version) (2007)
3. Lost in the Woods (2004)
4. Question Mark (2007)
5. Gossamer (2007)

Of course, you know there's plenty more I'd like, but I'd be beating a dead horse.....

[LostSoul]

Damn, forgot about Orpheus. Wouldn't mind that one.

RottingApples, on 15 March 2012 - 07:30 PM, said:

3. Lost in the Woods (2004)

OH, its like THAT, huh? In that case...

1. Lost In The Woods
2. Bit 5
3. Lonely Is The Name
4. Peace & Love
5. Spilled Milk

I was only doing SP before. :p/>

[RottingApples]

LostSoul, on 15 March 2012 - 07:32 PM, said:

Damn, forgot about Orpheus. Wouldn't mind that one.



OH, its like THAT, huh? In that case...

1. Lost In The Woods
2. Bit 5
3. Lonely Is The Name
4. Peace & Love
5. Spilled Milk

I was only doing SP before. :p/>

:lol:/> Too many greats. On the bright side, I do think there should be an unreleased studio version of Spilled Milk (ala Zwan DVD). Here's hoping he follows through on a Zwan reissue and we get our grubby hands on that gem. As I understand it, there should also be unreleased studio takes of Glorious, Cast a Stone, and of course the other tracks from the DVD.

[Dusty]

Glorious would be up there for me. I would include For Your Love too, but we have that really high quality radio broadcast of it acoustic, so that's really good enough for me. Same for 99 Floors, Peace+Love+Shit, Circular Change, etc.

Lonely Is The Name
March Hare
Adore Era Let Me Give The World to You
Glorious
Zeitgeist Sessions Gossamer

[smashp1979]

As Rome Burns
Question Mark
Pug (1999 version)
Lonely Is the Name
The Trip

[snail33]

question mark
the trip
baby
emerald green is the colour
west coast
into the light
the levitation
caroline, yes
make it happen
when the cock crows

PLUS

chrysanthemum
glorious
riverview
the shining path
the empty sea


would anyone argue that the following alternate version of tbk would not have been better than the one we have gotten so far?

a song for a son
question mark
baby
make it happen
emerald green is the colour
caroline, yes
west coast
spangled
the levitation
into the light
cottonwood symphony
when the cock crows
teargarden theme
the trip

[RottingApples]

snail33, on 16 March 2012 - 01:15 PM, said:

would anyone argue that the following alternate version of tbk would not have been better than the one we have gotten so far?

Sure. As would this:

http://www.smashingp...ndpost&p=660710


Honestly, any of those songs would have been better if the whole thing had been handled differently.

[themadcaplaughs]

Looking only at Smashing Pumpkins

1. No Surrender
2. Mama
3. As Rome Burns
4. Disco King (I know this is technically The Everlasting Gaze but still so drastically different it's almost a different song).
5. Let Me Give the World to You Adore version (still not confident it's that great, but we need to hear it to judge...the holy grail of unreleased SP)

If you throw Zwan in the mix...

My Life and Times
Love Lies in Ruins
Spilled Milk.

[BitterRootOfSelf]

As Rome Burns
Circular Change
Make it Happen
Gossamer!!!!
Caroline, Yes

[themadcaplaughs]

Never would have been interested in hearing a studio "Gossamer." It is a song meant to be played and enjoyed live, and I think the performance from If All Goes Wrong can be considered the definitive version.

[Hyrrow]

As Rome Burns
Mama
Spilled Milk
When The Cock Crows
The Shining Path

[Arachnea]

Circular Change
Gossamer
Lonely Is The Name
Mama
Bit 5
All of the Djali Zwan songs

[AndyToe]

She.
that is all

[Deleted User Account]

Lonely Is The Name
Emerald Green Is The Color
Caroline, Yes
99 Floors
Sound Of Silence

[beep beep]

99 Floors
Riverview
God's Gonna Set This World on Fire
Bobby Franks (w/ the Native America playing that wind instrument)
Bit 5

[aztec_litany_service]

girl with the cruel face
any other version or master of 'methusela' that exists
identify
speed
towers of rabble

any other pre-gish songs, especially any pre-jimmy songs. probably demos for all the 88 songs exist in pre-jimmy versions that he would've given the band to learn off of. in fact i remember darcy mentioning this, before she joined bc gave her some tapes, a lot of this stuff would be unheard stuff.

any other unreleased mcis material w/ vocals

[.absof.]

As Rome Burns
Gossamer
Pug (the way it was played live in '99 w/Jimmy)
99 Floors
Spilled Milk

[RottingApples]

aztec_litany_service, on 11 April 2012 - 03:05 PM, said:

any other unreleased mcis material w/ vocals

:thumbsup:/> Indeed.

[Deleted User Account]

aztec_litany_service, on 11 April 2012 - 03:05 PM, said:

[size="7"]girl with the cruel face[/s

Oh yeah. That's a really great tune. Shame.

[the_farewell_party]

"Lonely is the Name" (so long as they don't mess with it too much like what they did to Tom Tom)

"I Am My End" (some weird jam that seemed to combine "Offer Up" and "STP" [but I prefer it to both of those] and was similar to the "old Jellybelly" [you know, that song that sounds nothing like "Jellybelly" that Billy claims is an early "Jellybelly"]).

That's all I can think of for now. "Gossamer" needs no studio version, the live recordings are plently clear enough.